Scary Movie Pod
What's Your Favorite Scary Movie | The Cozy Horror Podcast
Pop your corn light a candle ️ double check your locks and snuggle in for What’s Your Favorite Scary Movie—the cozy horror podcast that feels like movie night with your best friends. Hosted by journalist and horror fanatic Parker Herren alongside former scary-skeptics turned genre-lovers Caroline and Ian Hoyt, we’re on a continuous quest to rank, review, and discuss cinema’s best (and worst) spooky flicks. What started in 2019 as an attempt to convert two scaredy-cats evolved into a cozy, chaotic hangout for horror fans of all levels. From brand-new theatrical releases and streaming gems to iconic slasher classics, we break down scares, rank memorable kills, and put releases head-to-head for the title of our favorite scary movie, plus expert film history deep-dives from guest historian Julieann Stipidis. Join the Hangout: Want us to read your review live on the show? Leave us a rating on Apple Podcasts! Follow Along: Catch full video episodes, vote on upcoming movie reviews, and check out the official leaderboard on YouTube, Instagram & TikTok: @scarymoviepod
© 2026 What's Your Favorite Scary Movie
Sign up to track rankings and reviews from Spotify, Apple Podcasts and more.